My elderly father was physically abusive, and will leave his farm to my two sisters. Should I contest his will?

I’m 12 and in 7th grade. My parents are divorced, and I earn $10 a month from my podcast. What do you advise?

Dear Moneyist,

I have 2 daughters. Growing up in an agricultural family during the farm crisis was tough. My dad was extremely abusive both physically and mentally. At 12 years old, he would pinch my ears with pliers. He told me once that he loved me, but he treated me like I was a farm worker, and always punished me if I didn’t do things just as he had asked.

He paid $10,000 a piece for my sisters’ weddings, and about the same for their divorces. I got nothing. He said: “Pay for girls. Not boys.” I am 52. Until 3 years ago when my mother divorced him due to his drinking, he would still ask me to come out to help on the farm. I did. Through counselling I realized I was looking for my father’s approval. I still am.

The Moneyist:‘More help is on the way’: The long wait is over for second stimulus check, but will $600 be enough?

So I did everything he asked. I just got berated all over again, and he told false stories to my family and community about me. He blamed me for his divorce from my mother. He wouldn’t talk to my sisters for a couple years either because of the divorce. My sisters told me that they had not spoken to him, but they had. They were always favored.

One sister now probably faces a big inheritance: the farm and equipment. I was told by several people that dad has me written out of his will. Everything will go to at least one sister, if not both. I am in Iowa. This is really hard to hear since I did most of the farm work growing up, and I was the only one to help as an adult. The girls are seeing him all the time now.

Should I contest the will when my father dies, assuming I am written out of it?

Neglected Son

Dear Son,

I advise against contesting the will. It will prolong the drama and trauma of your childhood. Thank your father for showing you how not to treat people. It is time to move on.

Whatever you are searching for, you will not find it in your father’s will. Any pain you have from your childhood will not be eradicated by a grand gesture in your father’s will, or by contesting it, even if you won, which would be an expensive, unlikely and emotionally draining process. The time has come for you to stop looking for that validation from your father.

The solution to your question has nothing to with your father’s farm, his will, or your sister’s marriages and divorces. Every time your father favors your sisters, you appear to re-experience the rejection you experienced as a child. He is your father, but he is also another human being who mistreated you and did not show you the love that you deserved. Money won’t fix that.

Want to read more?Follow Quentin Fottrell on Twitterand read more of his columns here.

Your father is another human being in the world, who raised you and unfortunately had total control over you as a child. He is a damaged person who seems to have serious problems with anger management, alcohol and a host of other unresolved traumas or resentments. But you can’t fix him, and you can’t fix your relationship with him. You can only fix yourself.

Your father once had all the power because you were financially dependent on him, and relied on him to show you how to make your way in the world. A parent should instill self belief in their child, and tell them that they should believe in themselves, and they are no better or nor worse than anyone else, and set them on a path to making healthy, positive choices.

Your father did not do that. You were a child who deserved better. But now you can choose to take that power back with therapy, and by creating financial and life goals that have absolutely nothing to do with your family. You are more than your sisters’ brother and your father’s son. You are your own man, and it’s time to break free from this dysfunctional family system.

Be the father your father never was. You can be generous with your time and your love and support. He has given you a gift: a template of how not to raise children.

The Moneyist: My friend’s father buried $50K in the backyard for his grandchildren. My friend has 2 kids, but his spendthrift brother has none. Should they split it?

Hello there, MarketWatchers. Check out the Moneyist private Facebook

 group where we look for answers to life’s thorniest money issues. Readers write in to me with all sorts of dilemmas.

Quentin Fottrell is MarketWatch’s Moneyist columnist. You can email The Moneyist with any financial and ethical questions at By emailing your questions, you agree to having them published anonymously on MarketWatch.

Source link


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here